91download.com supports a wide range of platforms, including YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, TikTok, Instagram, Dailymotion, Reddit, Bilibili, Douyin, Xiaohongshu and Zhihu, etc. Click the download button below to parse and download the current video
Have you ever wondered how accurate the reported death tolls during a war can be? In the heart-wrenching conflict between Israel and Gaza, the numbers have been a subject of intense debate. Let's delve into the question that's been on everyone's mind: How reliable are the Gaza Health authorities' figures?
On October 7th, when Hamas militants crossed into Israeli communities, the world watched in horror as the death toll climbed. Over 1,200 lives were lost, mostly civilians, and 253 hostages were taken into Gaza. The war, however, did not end there. Israel's ground and air campaign has since claimed more than 39,000 lives, according to Palestinian Health authorities. But are these numbers accurate?
President Joe Biden expressed doubt about the figures, yet the United Nations and the World Health Organization regularly cite them. Pre-war Gaza had robust population statistics and health information systems, which raises the question: How are these numbers compiled, and can they be trusted?
Initially, Gaza Health authorities counted bodies arriving at hospitals, recording names and identity numbers. However, the situation has changed dramatically. With fewer hospitals and morgues operational, the process has become less rigorous. Now, nearly a third of the toll includes unidentified bodies, and data input by grieving family members has been added.
Airwars, a London-based nonprofit, cross-referenced the health ministry's toll with their own list compiled from open-source monitoring. They found a correlation of at least 75%, indicating that the initial process was rigorous. But what about beyond that period?
The quality of information from Gaza has decline significantly. Internet blackouts and the loss of key personnel, either through evacuation or tragedy, have made accurate reporting challenging. As of May, 10,000 people were missing under the rubble, according to the Palestinian Health Ministry. If indirect deaths caused by disease are included, the toll could exceed 186,000, as suggested by a letter from three academics in The Lancet medical journal.
The complexity of the situation is further compounded by Hamas's control over Gaza's Health Ministry. While the enclave's health authority also answers to the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank, the extent of Hamas's influence is difficult to assess, given the Israeli occupation of most of the Gaza Strip.
Israeli officials have often cast doubt on the figures due to Hamas's control over the government. Yet, at times, Israel's military has acknowledged the toll as broadly reliable. The Gaza Health Ministry's figures do not differentiate between civilians and Hamas combatants, who do not wear uniforms or carry special IDs. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu claimed that the official toll included 14,000 Hamas fighters, but Hamas has not provided its own figures.
Airwars' findings suggest that at least some militants were included in the health ministry's list, adding another layer of complexity to the already intricate task of counting the dead.
The true death toll in Gaza remains a subject of contention. As we grapple with the human cost of this conflict, it's crucial to recognize the challenges in verifying these numbers. The question of accuracy is not just a matter of statistics; it's a reflection of the lives lost and the ongoing struggle for truth in the midst of war. How can we ensure that we are getting the full picture? The answer lies in transparency, international oversight, and a commitment to truth, even in the darkest of times.
Share on Twitter Share on Facebook